Reporting fatigue and the ESG rating and ranking industry

July 18, 2017

Does an increasingly crowded ESG rating and ranking landscape create unnecessary complexity and confusion when it comes to progressing the responsible investment agenda? Stephanie Mooij writes.

The rating and ranking industry of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) data has grown tremendously in the last decades[1].  This type of non-financial data is haunted by a lack of standards, consensus and understanding. ESG ratings and rankings exist to sort out this information for both practitioners and society at large. We better hope they do a good job as this industry is used by investors to allocate billions of capital, by companies to track their progress and by scholars in their search for the financial relevance of ESG. Given its widespread use, significance and recent questions around their reliability, I thought it would make for an interesting research topic[2].

According to the Raters initiative by SustainAbility, out of 108 ESG organizations investigated, about 60% need information from companies, such as questionnaires or interviews. This is quite burdensome, especially if you consider that there are currently at least 249 different products that rate, rank or index these companies[3].

If 60% of those need them to submit information this translates to 149 organizations with questionnaires and often opaque methods of assessment! According to my research, companies spend about half to a full-time post dealing with this, on top of their normal reporting functions (i.e. sustainability report). Research suggests a lack of convergence between the ratings that companies receive from various agencies[4]. This is not surprising given that there is simply no consensus on what ESG really is. Ratings often consist of hundreds of indicators, making the aggregate score a rather noisy proxy for ESG performance. Making scores even less convergent, are the subjective weights allocated to the different dimensions of ESG.

The questions around the credibility on the one hand, and the widespread use of this industry on the other hand, is reason for concern. If these ratings and rankings are not a good proxy for ESG performance, then billions of capital are potentially misallocated. Another problem is that most of the reported ESG data is not even audited. Therefore, not only the scores are debatable or subjective, but the input information as well. Companies are buried in these questionnaires and they need to make better use of their time.

I must stress here, that the industry has benefits. Investors, for example, tend to rely on ESG scores for efficiency reasons. They face the task of screening hundreds or even thousands of stocks and need quantitative measures to do so. This is why their preference goes out to those ESG raters with most coverage. Others may use ESG research reports to challenge their own viewpoints. Although using scores is inevitable for most investors, this does not imply that they are not aware of the pitfalls. In fact, some have established cross-checking methods and will investigate if there are discrepancies for large holdings. On the company level, there are also indisputable benefits. First off, having their improvement points highlighted, is tremendously helpful. Second, it creates a sense of urgency among top management to get things done. This is especially necessary as, according to my research, investors and companies often fail to have a proper conversation about ESG issues. Discussions are still dominated by short-term financial questions and analysts often lack the training or expertise to talk about ESG. Companies thus tend to use input from ESG ratings and rankings as a proxy for investors demand.

Overall, there is nothing wrong with using input from third-parties, but how many of these intermediaries with divergent opinions do companies need to actively engage with? Perhaps a handful is enough? Shareholders should make it clear which ones they find most valuable, in order to allow companies to prioritise. Equally, companies should know what information their shareholders deem necessary. Sustainability managers should think about what ratings or rankings align with their strategy. Another possibility is to opt for those with most coverage, as these are the ones investors tend to use. Time can be used to focus their efforts and to communicate the materiality of their ESG progress more clearly, instead of more often. This discussion is equally important between investors and their clients, as problems may arise if different rating providers are used. Blindly relying on ratings is not a good idea in any case, as (1) rating agencies make mistakes and (2) it is another organizations opinion on what matters.

Stephanie Mooij is Doctoral Researcher at the Smith School of Enterprise and the Environment, University of Oxford.

 

[1]For example, see the rate the raters project by SustainAbility: http://sustainability.com/rate-the-raters/

[2] For full research paper see Mooij, Stephanie, The ESG Initiative Industry; Vice or Virtue in the Adoption of Responsible Investment? (April 11, 2017). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2960869 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2960869

[3] See www.ratesustainability.org/hub. This is just the tip of the iceberg as other estimates are much larger.

[4] Chatterji, A.K., Durand, R., Levine, D.I., Touboul, S., 2015. Do ratings of firms converge? Implications for managers, investors and strategy researchers. Strategic Management Journal. | Dorfleitner, G., Halbritter, G., Nguyen, M., 2015. Measuring the level and risk of corporate responsibility – An empirical comparison of different ESG rating approaches. Journal of Asset Management 16, 450–466.

COMMENTS

  1. Marilyn Johnson

    Great article Stephanie, and a reminder to everyone involved – as an assessor, a company being assessed, or others that are using the 3rd party ratings and rankings – that the purpose, scope and limitations of any assessment is as important as the content itself. Once that is understood in context, 3rd party assessments serve a tremendous purpose in setting goals, staying focused on material issues, identifying priorities and opportunities, benchmarking and continuing to make progress forward.

    I agree that alignment with strategy is key. It is not necessary nor practical for a ‘one size fits all’, but rather finding the right fit, and sifting through the nearly 250 assessments to focus on those that have the most credibility, importance and relevance to your company strategy and stakeholders.

    Reply ↓
  2. Tsewpf

    Even if your date is excellent in talking English, she’ll value the truth that you made the initiative to learn her language just to be able to speak to her pleasantly. If you’re dating a Latina, you can be confident that she’ll put you and your family first. For this reason, whether you’re inviting your Latina close friend for coffee or your day for supper, it may be a good idea to place a pillow on your schedule. Thus, going out on a date with a Latina would be like dating Juliet in the 21st century. Ought to you desire to date a Latina, it’s important to get a glimpse of that they are from afar. When dating a Latina, expect her to speak about her life and career objectives. Be sure to talk about openly regarding your assumptions and goals for the future of your connection if you’re presently in a connection with a Latina. Start with the Compatibility Quiz to make sure that we discover songs you’re most likely to strike it off with.

    If you’re really feeling nervous concerning taking your love life online, you shouldn’t! Those are abilities that are mosting likely to make you effective whatever you perform in life. Whether you desire a hulk or a gorgeous Latin damsel, you will obtain the love of your life at this site. Combined with an anti microbial lining and socking, and a sports quality ankle joint assistance, you will certainly have the ability to practice and complete for longer and with higher strength than with other brands. Even though an older woman might have the same BMI as a more youthful lady, the older woman will likely have less muscular tissue mass and even more body fat, which raise her threat of illness. The lady is clothed for a cabaret performance of some kind; the youngster is defeated by the lady and the man is shown gaming consoling the kid who rests on the floor of what we assume is the cabaret where she works. Yet there are lots of things that you ought to never perform with a lady from Latin countries.

    Latin females see and value the important things you are doing for them, and they never ever miss out on a possibility to applaud you when you need it. Her doing his washing takes it off of your hands. Although they can’t turn their hips or persuade their hands like other gifted dancers, they have fantastic rhythm and recognize some great actions, too! Instead, it’s due to the fact that she cares and loves for you in ways you can not picture. Third, we can not aid who we are. I strongly keep in mind checking out a scholarship application from one student who described exactly how songs was her escape and relief while living in her nation. For many Latinas, fantastic professional dancers are the ones that are positive adequate to relocate their rigid bodies. Costard has utilized “ad dunghill” due to the fact that it sounds enough like “advertisement unguem,” a Latin phrase for something being done to an exact procedure or requirement. When they like a person, they tell them concerning it-sometimes, also when they have just understood somebody for a week. Possibly, their enthusiastic displays of love in the direction of their companions might have led people to think this. This research may-or may not-explain why many Latinas like to engage in public screens of love.

    Generally, Latin Americans like to show their love almost everywhere. While the globe has actually become more tranquil and loosened up regarding their feelings, Latinxs, in basic, latamdate review choose to remain as passionate and expressive as ever. According to research pertaining to early advancement and parenting, Hispanic mommies are much more affectionate and have extra skin-to-skin undamaged with their infants than Anglo mothers. The elections will certainly be reviewed according to 4 major aspects: (a) development field, based upon deposited patents and established items or procedures; (b) management area, based on the sychronisation of groups, jobs or work groups, the transfer of knowledge to their groups and job teams, or the production of startups; (c) acknowledgment field, based on previous honors, recognitions and promotions within and outside their business; (d) exterior communication area, based on the advancement of research jobs in collaboration with universities, study establishments and partner companies. If you ever before end up being a component of her household you will instantaneously be approved and treated as necessary. Dancing belongs to Latina ladies’s everyday routine, especially the seniors.

    Reply ↓